- Kuzari: Reason vs Faith
- Moshe Ben-Chaim
- Reader: Would you please explain to me the Kuzari's position
on faith which he talks about at the end of section 2:26 and 5:1? He
seems to imply that one who keeps the Torah based on faith is on a
higher level than one who "resorts" to rational reasons
behind the mitzvot. How can this position be reconciled with his
emphasis on the proof of Torah from Sinai? Thank you for your time.
- Mesora: Kuzari,
chapter 5:1 does not seem to indicate what you suggest, but 2:26 does,
but only on the surface. When completing his views in his discourse on
the Temple's service and maintenance by the Levites, the Rabbi writes:
"I do not by any means, assert that the service was instituted in
the order expounded by me, since it entailed something more secret and
higher, and was based on divine law. He who accepts this completely
without scrutiny or argument, is better off than he who investigates
and analyzes. He, however, who steps down from the highest grade to
scrutiny, does well to turn his face to the latent wisdom, instead of
leading it to evil opinions and doubts which lead to corruption."
- The Rabbi, Judah Halevi, is not defending faith over analysis. That
is nonsensical, and cannot be followed, even if the Rabbi said it,
which he would not. We don't follow "people" regardless of
their reputation. We follow reason. And by definition, reason demands
explanation which is the result of analysis. Faith has no place in
man's search for knowledge.
- The Rabbi clearly states that when one is involved in the
"secrets" of the law, he is better off to accept them,
rather than plunge into an area where his abilities fall short. By
"secrets", he refers to areas where man's abilities are
weakest, an can lead to erroneous notions. For this reason, he states
one should turn to areas where he can detect "latent"
wisdom, areas where eventually, accurate ideas can become evident. In
opposition to latent wisdom are those areas beyond man's reach.
"Four entered the garden,.....and Rabbi Akiva exited in
peace." (Talmud Chagiga, 14b) The other three did not. This case
refers to the involvement in areas above one's capabilities.
- The Rabbi's message here is that one must take care not to enter
areas beyond his comprehension. In no way is he suggesting that faith
is a better choice than analysis and reason. His entire work displays
analysis and reason. You must certainly agree the part cannot
represent the whole. If you still understand this part to mean that
faith outweighs reason, then you do best to convince yourself of the
Rabbi's intent by realizing that the rest of his work implored one to
engage reason, so he cannot contradict himself. That would not be
Philosophy | Tnach
| New Postings
| Audio Archives | Suggested
Reading | Live
Classes | Search | Letters
| Q&A's | Community
Action | Volunteer | Links
| Education | Chat
| Banners | Classifieds | Advertise
| Donors | About
Us | Press
| Contacts | Home
Mesora website designed by NYDesign.com
© 2003 Mesora of New York, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Articles may be reprinted without permission.